Skip to content

Initial baryon temperature of small_cosmo_volume example seems wrong #52

@apontzen

Description

@apontzen

In small_cosmo_volume.yml, the initial temperature of the baryons at z~=50 is set to ~7000K. An accompanying comment says (1 + z_ini)^2 * 2.72K.

This temperature seems far too high, and the comment makes it sound like it's a mistake rather than intentional. Baryons thermally decouple from the CMB photons at z~150, and only after that time would their temperature redshift as (1+z)^2. Thus, a more appropriate temperature would seem to be T_cmb (1+z)^2 / (1+z_dec) which comes to ~45K, below the temperature floor for the simulation.

Other examples give more reasonable initialisation temperatures, e.g. eagle_50.yml initialises to T=268.7K at z=127, which seems sensible. Given that it is quoted to 4 significant figures, perhaps it's based on a more detailed calculation than the above hand-waving (which would produce a slightly higher estimate).

I have never played much with changing initialisation temperatures. I would assume the effect is fairly modest, but such an extreme discrepancy in the provided small_cosmo_volume.yml example seems like it could generate unphysical thermal smoothing effects at early times. Is there a specific reason for it?

Metadata

Metadata

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions