Skip to content

requesting fields that require missing snapshot fields #170

@dnelson86

Description

@dnelson86

This is perhaps an architectural question, or a question about the philosophy behind the parameter files.

For a run of compute_halo_properties I see messages as:

The following properties were not found in the parameter file, but will be calculated:
(lots of fields)

The following properties were found in the parameter file, but are invalid:
(lots of fields)

But then I land at errors, that terminate execution, as:

The following properties require PartType0/TotalDustMassFractions:
  DustMass
  HalfMassRadiusDust
"Can't find required dataset PartType0/TotalDustMassFractions in input file(s)!"

The question is: why not automatically skip fields to be computed, if the required information is not there?

The current situation (for me, not knowing what I'm doing) is that I have to keep adding exclusions to the parameter file, until the run actually proceeds. In particular, what I am doing now is slowly "fixing" parameter_files/FLAMINGO.yml to work on a local copy I have of L1000N0900/HYDRO_FIDUCIAL.

I understand this isn't an issue for large production runs, where everything is fixed and big SOAP runs should be stable and reproducible, but for testing/development when there are many smaller runs, possibly with evolving snapshot fields, it seems a less manual approach to specifying/deciding what quantities to compute would be advantageous.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions